GED2HTML - a review

I have looked at the shareware version 2.4a of Gene Stark's GED2HTML: A GEDCOM to HTML Translator.

My mainpoints of concern are:

  1. The link-structure is based on the INDI-ID's in the GEDCOM-file. Coupled to the alphabetical grouping in sub-indices this does lock the web-structure. An addition to the database might cause a rearrangement of all the references.
  2. I prefer one person on each web-page. This is possible in GED2HTML, but it is designed for a several persons on each page, resulting in a complicated - and unstable - html-reference.
  3. It is a closed structure - it is not possible to automatically link to pages outside the given GED2HTML-structure. It can offcourse be done manually after the automatic generation, but it would be a tedious job - and should be repeated after reruns of a modified GEDCOM-file.
To clarify these points I have made a small demonstration based on 7 and 9 persons. For each of these I have made a single-file and a single-person GED2HTML-translation. The Index and Anchestor Chart below are taken from the 9 person single-file version. The two emphasized persons are excluded from the 7 person structure. Thats the wife and a child of Jørgen Jensen Friis. They are the last two persons in the 9 person GEDCOM-file and offcourse not present in the 7 person GEDCOM-file.

The single-file versions ( 7 and 9 ) have been produced with the standard-settings of GED2HTML, whereas the single-person versions ( 7 and 9 ) have been produced with:

In this small example, the single-file versions are acceptable. The people are closely related so it is not too confusing to have them in one long row. But even here I do prefer a single-person solution - BUT...

As you can see from the Index of Persons, Louise Marie Friis is placed as number 5 in the version with 9 persons. This changes the references for the rest of the list. E.g. Cathrine Elisabeth Hauge is moved from the reference ../d0002/g0000005.htm#I7 to ../d0002/g0000006.htm#I7.

This is rather confusing - especially if someone will reference a specific web-page. A robot, indexing the site, will return erronoeus information after such a restructuring operation.

I will also mention two minor points:

  1. A proper genealogy-database have an extensive list of references. As far as I can see, this will result in a huge SOURCES.HTM in GED2HTML.
  2. PC-users should be aware of the character set. GED2HTML (and WWW) assumes the Latin-1 character set, so you should translate your GEDCOM-file if you are using an IBM-charset (allthough the GEDCOM have a CHAR-descriptor in the header). I have done that for the 9-person case, but not for the 7-person case.
Finally I have produced my own translation of the BK-data for the 9 persons, I have used here. You are welcome to have a look at FamilyWeb, version 2

Index of Persons

Bodil Kjestine FRIIS (__.__.1812 - __.__.1855 )
Jacob Jensen FRIIS (__.__.1832 - __.__.1902 )
Jørgen Jensen FRIIS (02.12.1878 - 30.05.1975 )
Jørgen Jensen FRIIS (__.__.1801 - __.__.1872 )
Louise Marie FRIIS (28.12.1910 - 30.08.1987 )
Cathrine Elisabeth HAUGE (__.__.1804 - __.__.1861 )
Kjestine Marie HAUGE (__.__.1841 - __.__.1931 )
Mads Jensen HAUGE (__.__.1804 - __.__.1889 )
Inger Sophie KROGH (21.02.1883 - 11.08.1965 )

Ancestor chart

                                                _Jørgen Jensen FRIIS ______
                        _Jacob Jensen FRIIS ___|
                       |                       |_Bodil Kjestine FRIIS _____
 _Jørgen Jensen FRIIS _|
|                      |                        _Mads Jensen HAUGE ________
|                      |_Kjestine Marie HAUGE _|
|                                              |_Cathrine Elisabeth HAUGE _
|
|--Louise Marie FRIIS 
|
|                                               ___________________________
|                       _______________________|
|                      |                       |___________________________
|_Inger Sophie KROGH __|
                       |                        ___________________________
                       |_______________________|
                                               |___________________________


To top of this page. Information om FamilieNet / FamilyWeb
Written by Jørgen Bak 20 OCT 1996.